One
of the questions which a day like Columbus Day presents is not whether or not
Columbus should be celebrated, but what should be done instead of celebration. Columbus’
diaries and the historical record speak abundantly to the reasons for not
celebrating Columbus, but should we perhaps celebrate another exemplar? Should
we, as Seattle has recently done, reform the day into Indigenous
People’s Day? Or should there be
perhaps another exemplar celebrated, such as Bartolome de las Casas?In looking at this day from the perspective of nonviolence, there seems to be no easy answer, and certainly no perfect exemplar. Columbus, as the historical record attests, engaged in slavery, forced labor, and dismemberment of the indigenous people. The indigenous people were no pacifists, engaging in skirmishes with their neighbors. De las Casas, while famously advocating against the Spanish enslavement of the indigenous people, initially proposed that the Spanish enslave Africans instead of the North American natives. Any alternate celebration, while moving away from Columbus, only appears to celebrate violence again in a different form.

